My Contention About Genesis 6:4
So many people and Bible people as well claim that the Nephilim were the offspring of the daughters of men and the sons of God. However, read the verses closely and we will examine this in great detail.
"There were giants in the earth in those days; and also after that, when the sons of God came in unto the daughters of men, and they bare children to them, the same became mighty men which were of old, men of renown."- Genesis 6:4
Key Points in the Verse:
"There were giants in the earth in those days;"
- The Hebrew word translated as "giants" is Nephilim, which can also mean "fallen ones." This phrase establishes that the Nephilim existed during the specific time being referenced, but it does not directly connect their origin to the "sons of God" and "daughters of men."
"And also after that,"
- This phrase indicates that the Nephilim existed both before and after the sons of God took the daughters of men as wives and produced offspring. This suggests that the Nephilim's existence was not dependent on that union.
"When the sons of God came in unto the daughters of men, and they bare children to them,"
- This part describes a separate event where the sons of God intermingled with the daughters of men and produced offspring. The passage states that these offspring became "mighty men" (gibborim), "men of renown," which may indicate heroic figures or individuals of significant reputation.
Separation of Nephilim from the Offspring of the Sons of God and Daughters of Men:
- The verse does not explicitly equate the Nephilim with the offspring of this union. Instead, it seems to describe two distinct groups: the Nephilim, who were already present, and the "mighty men" who were born as a result of the union.
My Contention:
My argument that the Nephilim are not the offspring of the sons of God and daughters of men aligns with a close reading of the text. The Nephilim are mentioned as being present before the union and still existing after it, suggesting they were a separate category of beings.
Theological and Interpretive Views:
Traditional Fallen Angel View:
- Many interpret the "sons of God" as fallen angels who interbred with human women, resulting in the Nephilim as their offspring. However, this interpretation relies heavily on extra-biblical texts like the Book of Enoch and may not fully align with the Genesis narrative.
Human Lineage View:
- Others argue that the "sons of God" were godly descendants of Seth, while the "daughters of men" were from the ungodly line of Cain. This union produced "mighty men" but does not necessarily explain the Nephilim.
"Nephilim as Pre-Flood Beings":
- My contention finds support in the idea that the Nephilim were an entirely separate group or race, existing before the flood and continuing afterward. This could imply they were a pre-existing group with extraordinary characteristics, distinct from the offspring of the "sons of God" and "daughters of men."
Implications of the Phrase "Also After That":
The statement "and also after that" is key to my argument. If the Nephilim existed both before and after the events of Genesis 6:2-4, they cannot solely be the result of that union. This supports the idea that the Nephilim were a pre-existing group, perhaps survivors or a recurring phenomenon.
More Thoughts:
My interpretation is plausible and aligns with a literal reading of Genesis 6:4. The text does not directly equate the Nephilim with the offspring of the sons of God and daughters of men, and the mention of their existence "in those days, and also after that" points to them being a distinct group.
Let's explore other ancient texts, such as the Book of Enoch, or delve into historical and linguistic studies on the Nephilim for further context.
The Book of Enoch
The Book of Enoch, a non-canonical text in most Christian traditions, elaborates on Genesis 6:4 and the Nephilim. While it is not considered Scripture by most, it was influential in early Jewish and Christian thought.
The Watchers (1 Enoch 6-7):
- Enoch describes a group of angels, called the Watchers, who descended to Earth, lusted after human women, and produced giant offspring (Nephilim). This union is said to corrupt humanity and lead to widespread sin, eventually prompting the flood.
- These giants are depicted as ravenous and destructive, consuming all available resources and even turning on humanity.
Judgment on the Watchers:
- The text attributes the corruption of humanity to the Watchers’ actions, leading God to imprison them and destroy their offspring through the flood.
The Fate of the Nephilim’s Spirits:
- After their death, the spirits of the Nephilim are said to become demons, tormenting humanity.
Connection to Genesis 6: The Book of Enoch expands on Genesis 6, providing a mythological explanation for the Nephilim’s origin. However, Genesis itself does not mention the Watchers explicitly, suggesting a more nuanced or separate understanding of the Nephilim in the Biblical text. This will of course raise the question if the Book of Enoch is fraudulent or not.
Linguistic and Historical Insights
The Word Nephilim:
- The Hebrew root naphal (נפל) means "to fall." Thus, Nephilim is often translated as "fallen ones." However, this etymology is debated.
- Some scholars suggest the term refers to their reputation or stature, meaning "giants" or "those who cause others to fall in battle."
Gibborim and the Mighty Men:
- The term gibborim (גִּבּוֹרִים) in Genesis 6:4 means "mighty men" or "warriors." It refers to the offspring of the "sons of God" and "daughters of men," but it is not synonymous with the Nephilim.
Pre-Flood and Post-Flood Context:
Other Ancient Texts and Traditions
Jubilees:
- Like Enoch, the Book of Jubilees describes the Nephilim as the offspring of divine beings and human women. It also emphasizes their wickedness and destructive impact on the Earth.
Dead Sea Scrolls:
- The scrolls reference the Watchers and the Nephilim, showing that these traditions were widespread in Second Temple Judaism.
Greek Mythology Parallels:
- Some compare the Nephilim to the Greek Titans, divine beings born from the union of gods and mortals. Both are often depicted as giants with extraordinary power, ultimately defeated by divine intervention.
Theological Interpretations Across Time
Early Jewish and Christian Thought:
- Early interpreters, such as Philo of Alexandria and Josephus, aligned with the angelic interpretation of Genesis 6:4, connecting the Nephilim to fallen angels.
- Early church fathers, including Justin Martyr and Irenaeus, supported this view, seeing the Nephilim as part of a broader narrative of spiritual warfare.
Reformation and Beyond:
- Some theologians, like John Calvin, rejected the angelic interpretation, viewing the "sons of God" as the godly line of Seth intermarrying with the ungodly line of Cain.
Key Questions for Our Research
Who Were the Nephilim?
- Are they a distinct race created independently of human-angelic unions?
- Could they represent a pre-Adamic or pre-flood race tied to early humanity’s mythology?
What Does "Also After That" Mean?
- Does it suggest a recurring phenomenon of divine-human interaction or a symbolic reappearance of their traits (e.g., might, corruption)?
Post-Flood Survival:
- Were the Nephilim present in Canaan due to a second incursion, or were they metaphorical figures exaggerating the strength of the Canaanites?
Resources for Further Study
- Books:
- The Unseen Realm by Michael S. Heiser explores Genesis 6 and the divine council worldview.
- Giants: Sons of the Gods by Douglas Van Dorn provides a biblical and historical analysis of the Nephilim.
- Texts:
- The Book of Enoch (accessible translations with commentary).
- Dead Sea Scroll fragments on the Watchers and Nephilim.
- Linguistic Studies:
- Examine the Hebrew roots and contexts of terms like Nephilim and gibborim.
Linguistic Studies on the Nephilim
Etymology of Nephilim:
- The Hebrew term נְפִלִים (Nephilim) derives from the root naphal (נפל), meaning "to fall" or "fallen ones." Scholars debate whether this refers to:
- Fallen Beings: Suggesting they were supernatural entities or beings cast down from heaven (angels or divine beings).
- Fallen Heroes: Suggesting they were mortal warriors who fell in battle and gained a mythical reputation.
- Overshadowed Groups: Suggesting the name implies a suppressed or overshadowed race, possibly connected to their depiction as "giants."
- The Hebrew term נְפִלִים (Nephilim) derives from the root naphal (נפל), meaning "to fall" or "fallen ones." Scholars debate whether this refers to:
Comparison with Gibborim:
- The term gibborim (גִּבּוֹרִים) in Genesis 6:4 is distinct from Nephilim. It is typically translated as "mighty men" or "heroes." Some scholars suggest the offspring of the "sons of God" and "daughters of men" were gibborim, while the Nephilim were a separate group.
Ancient Translations:
- Septuagint (LXX): Translates Nephilim as "gigantes" (giants). This translation likely influenced the interpretation of them as physically enormous beings.
- Aramaic Targums: Often expand on the biblical text, referring to the Nephilim as tyrannical rulers or warriors.
- Dead Sea Scrolls: Refer to the Nephilim in the context of their role in cosmic rebellion, emphasizing their connection to the Watchers.
Archaeological and Historical Evidence
Physical Evidence:
- Claims of giant skeletons have surfaced over the centuries, but many have been hoaxes or misinterpretations of large human remains or megafauna.
- Despite limited credible physical evidence, ancient cultures globally have myths of giants (e.g., Goliath in the Bible, the Titans in Greece, or the Jotnar in Norse mythology), possibly hinting at a shared archetype or exaggerated memory of tall or powerful individuals.
References in Ancient Cultures:
- Mesopotamian Context: Stories like the Epic of Gilgamesh feature demigods or beings of extraordinary size and strength, similar to the gibborim and Nephilim.
- Canaanite Influence: The Anakim, Rephaim, and other "giant clans" mentioned in the Bible (e.g., Numbers 13:33, Deuteronomy 2:10-11) may be linked to Canaanite myths or a historical memory of a distinct people group.
Megastructures and Myths:
- Some attribute ancient monumental architecture (e.g., pyramids, ziggurats, and megaliths) to the Nephilim or similar beings, though these claims lack concrete evidence. Such structures were more likely built by advanced ancient civilizations rather than a "giant race."
Theological Debates
Who Are the "Sons of God"?
- Divine Beings View: Interpreted as angels or spiritual entities based on Job 1:6, where "sons of God" refers to heavenly beings.
- Line of Seth View: Seen as godly descendants of Seth intermarrying with the ungodly descendants of Cain. This interpretation avoids supernatural implications.
- Royalty View: Some see "sons of God" as ancient kings or rulers claiming divine descent.
Why the Flood?
- The union of the "sons of God" and "daughters of men" is often cited as a primary reason for the flood in Genesis. This suggests a deep corruption of God's intended order, either through angelic rebellion or human sin.
Post-Flood Nephilim:
- How the Nephilim appear after the flood raises theological questions. Options include:
- Survival: Some propose that the flood was local or that Nephilim survived on Noah’s ark.
- Recurrence: Others argue that similar unions occurred after the flood.
- Symbolic Survival: The term "Nephilim" may have been used figuratively for powerful or corrupt individuals.
- How the Nephilim appear after the flood raises theological questions. Options include:
Demonology and the Nephilim:
- Some traditions hold that the spirits of the dead Nephilim became demons. This idea is rooted in the Book of Enoch and aligns with the view that demons are disembodied spirits seeking embodiment (e.g., Mark 5:12).
Global Parallels and Interpretations
Greek Titans:
- The Titans were giant offspring of Uranus (sky) and Gaia (earth). Like the Nephilim, they were overthrown by the Olympian gods. Both stories involve divine beings, rebellion, and a catastrophic judgment.
Norse Jotnar (Giants):
- In Norse mythology, the Jotnar were a race of giants in opposition to the gods (Aesir). While not directly linked to humanity, their role as adversaries parallels interpretations of the Nephilim as corrupt and rebellious.
Hindu Asuras:
- Hindu texts describe the Asuras as powerful beings opposing the Devas (gods), with some unions between gods and humans producing extraordinary beings.
Research Directions for You
- Deepen Linguistic Study:
- Study the Hebrew terms Nephilim and gibborim in their biblical and extrabiblical contexts. Examine commentaries on Genesis and Numbers for interpretations.
- Compare Mythologies:
- Look into comparative mythology to see how other cultures depict giants, divine unions, or fallen beings.
- Investigate Historical Claims:
- Research archaeological claims of giants and the cultural contexts that may have inspired these traditions.
- Theological Implications:
- Explore how different theological traditions interpret Genesis 6:4 and its implications for spiritual warfare, human sin, and divine judgment.
Conclusion
If you are like me, you believe the Bible that clearly states that these beings, the Nephilim are not the offspring of the sons of God and woman. In further posts on the #Nephilim we will explore the Book of Enoch and others to determine if they are legitimate, partially true, or a fraud altogether. I look forward to your comments below.